Posted: Mar 18, 2006
| Date | Match-Up | Time | Result |
| Saturday, March 18 |
Wittenberg def. Pitt-Bradford | 10 a.m. | 6-5 |
| Saturday, March 18 |
Pitt-Bradford def. Hiram | 1 p.m. | 13-11 |
| Saturday, March 18 |
John Carroll def. Hiram | 4 p.m. | 13-1 |
| Sunday, March 19 |
Hiram def. Wittenberg | 10 a.m. | 8-6 |
| Sunday, March 19 |
Pitt-Bradford def. John Carroll | 1 p.m. | 12-1 |
| Sunday, March 19 |
Wittenberg def. John Carroll | 4 p.m. | 12-3 |