Senior Connor Seipel enters his senior season having amassed 1028 points in 87 games played for the Red and White. Seipel comes off a strong season where he earned All-NCAC First Team honors, along with D3Hoops.com Great Lakes Region First Team Honors and capping his award total with NABC Great Lakes All-District Second Team honors. Seipel led the NCAC in shooting percentage on the season, knocking down 67.5 percent of his attempts. Seipel averaged 17 points and 10 rebounds per game for the Red and White during his junior year. The Tiger's finished the 2018-19 campaign with a 24-6 overall record, finishing with a 14-4 mark in NCAC action. Along the way, Wittenberg collected their second consecutive NCAC Tournament title, while making their NCAA DIII record 29th tournament appearance.
Wittenberg will travel to Brooklyn College to begin their 2019-20 journey.
| First Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| G | Booker Coplin | Augsburg | Sr. | Shakopee, Minnesota |
| G | Jake Ross | Springfield | Sr. | Northampton, Massachusetts |
| F | Connor Raridon | North Central (Ill.) | Sr. | Plainfield, Illinois |
| F | Zac O'Dell | Swarthmore | Sr. | Schenectady, New York |
| C | Jack Flynn | UW-Oshkosh | Sr. | Appleton, Wisconsin |
| Second Team | ||||
| G | Kena Gilmour | Hamilton | Sr. | New Paltz, New York |
| G | Ben College | Whitworth | Sr. | Portland, Oregon |
| F | Sam Toney | New Jersey City | Sr. | Plainfield, New Jersey |
| F | Connor Seipel | Wittenberg | Sr. | Columbus, Ohio |
| F | Will Carius | Monmouth | Sr. | Bettendorf, Iowa |
| Third Team | ||||
| G | Nate West | LeTourneau | Sr. | Houston, Texas |
| G | Jake Rhode | Elmhurst | Jr. | Chicago Heights, Illinois |
| G | Dimitrius Underwood | Texas-Dallas | Sr. | Mesquite, Texas |
| F | Justin Summers | Brockport | Sr. | Brooklyn, New York |
| F | Kevin Dennis | Morrisville State | Sr. | Bronx, New York |
| Fourth Team | ||||
| G | Grant Robinson | Amherst | Jr. | McLean, Virginia |
| G | Buzz Anthony | Randolph-Macon | Jr. | Arnold, Maryland |
| G | Jack Davidson | Wabash | Jr. | Fishers, Indiana |
| F | Gabe Leifer | Yeshiva | Sr. | Lawrence, New York |
| F | Will Crumly | Covenant | Jr. | Marietta, Georgia |
| Honorable Mention | ||||
| G | Brian Cameron | Wesley | Sr. | Newark, Delaware |
| G | Romin Williams | Emory | Jr. | Harvey, Louisiana |
| G | Ethan Bublitz | UW-Stevens Point | Sr. | Jackson, Wisconsin |
| F | Adam Fravert | UW-Oshkosh | Sr. | Marshfield, Wisconsin |
| F | Nate Shafer | Swarthmore | Sr. | McLean, Virginia |