2013 Men's All-Tournament Team

Ali Mix, Kean
Michael Burton, Kean
Jake Stafford, Marian
Sam Collins, Wittenberg
Steven Newell, Wittenberg
Scott Masin, Wittenberg (MVP)

2012 Men's All-Tournament Team

James Barton, Bethany
Ryan Nowicki, Hanover
Nate Kasper, Taylor
Sam Collins, Wittenberg
Scott Masin, Wittenberg
Casey Coons, Taylor (MVP)

2011 Men's All-Tournament Team

Matt El, Olivet
Michael DeDecker, Monmouth
Alex Sylvester, Marian
Aaron Evans, Marian
Josh McKee, Wittenberg
Clayton Black, Wittenberg (MVP)
 

2010 Men's All-Tournament Team

Jonathan Jones, Kean
Dane Givner, Heidelberg
Casey Coons, Taylor
Tommy Peller, Taylor
Chris Sullivan, Wittenberg
Clayton Black, Wittenberg (MVP)
 

2009 Men's All-Tournament Team

Aaron Gibbs, Ohio Dominican
Michael McClary, Olivet
Jordan Tucker, Marian
Anthony Furlin, Marian
Mark Snyder, Wittenberg
Gregg Hill, Wittenberg (MVP)
 

2008 Men's All-Tournament Team

Michael Romes, MSJ
Michael Cooper, Wittenberg
Kevin Murray, Wittenberg
Alex Daniel, Taylor
Ben Panner, Wheaton
Kent Raymond, Wheaton (MVP)
 

2007 Men's All-Tournament Team

Tyler Kleinschmidt, Marian University
Michael McClary, Olivet College
Austin Scott, University of Wisconsin-La Crosse
Tony Mane, University of Wisconsin-La Crosse
Gregg Hill, Wittenberg University
Brandan Barabino, Wittenberg University (MVP)
 

2006 Men's All-Tournament Team

Jeffrey Boone, York College
Joe Hermann, Thiel College
Tyler Butcher, Indiana University-Southeast
David Nowicki, Wittenberg University
Mark Caraway, Wittenberg University
Dane Borchers, Wittenberg University (MVP)
 

2005 Men's All-Tournament Team

Gerald Dozie, Olivet
Derek Huffman, Marian
Daniel Russ, Wittenberg
Tyler Howard, Wittenberg
Dane Borchers, Wittenberg (MVP)
 

2004 Men's All-Tournament Team

Randy Sistrunk, Walsh
Marquice Woods, Purdue Calumet
Doug Bell, Taylor
Kenny Molz, Wittenberg
Daniel Russ, Wittenberg
Dane Borchers, Wittenberg (MVP)