Posted: Jun 01, 2021
Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools.
Player of the Year: Brian McAuliffe, 1B, Sr., Denison
Pitcher of the Year: Henry Litman, Jr., Washington and Jefferson
Rookie of the Year: Joe Olsavsky, 2B, John Carroll
Coach of the Year: Jeff Mountain, Washington and Jefferson
| First Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Gunner Rainey | Adrain | Sr. | Adrian, Mich. |
| 1B | Brian McAuliffe | Denison | Sr. | Tuckahoe, N.Y. |
| 2B | Joe Olsavsky | John Carroll | Fr. | Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| SS | Alex Ludwick | Baldwin Wallace | Sr. | Brunswick, Ohio |
| 3B | C.J. Saylor | Grove City | So. | Lancaster, Pa. |
| OF | Ryan Bixler | Franklin | Sr. | Logansport, Ind. |
| OF | Turner Hill | Marietta | Sr. | Marietta, Ohio |
| OF | Will Krushena | Denison | Sr. | Bloomfield Hills, Mich. |
| DH | Danny Dopp | Earlham | Sr. | South Haven, Mich. |
| UTL | Tyler Horvat | Washington & Jefferson | So. | Irwin, Pa. |
| SP | Pierce Banks | Adrian | Sr. | Sterling Heights, Mich. |
| SP | Henry Litman | Washington & Jefferson | Jr. | Marietta, Ga. |
| SP | Jake Seymour | La Roche | Sr. | Allison Park, Pa. |
| RP | Sam Mathews | Marietta | Jr. | Fairfield, Ohio |
| Second Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Jack Hollinshead | Wittenberg | Sr. | Highland Heights, Ohio |
| 1B | Drew Holderbach | Marietta | Jr. | Fairfield, Ohio |
| 2B | Hudson Chastain | Transylvania | Sr. | Knoxville, Tenn. |
| SS | Tyler Chumita | Wooster | Jr. | Hilliard, Ohio |
| 3B | Jake Hillard | Penn State Altoona | Fr. | State College, Pa. |
| OF | Keaton Mark | Heidelberg | Sr. | Oneonta, N.Y. |
| OF | Zack Mazza | Mount Union | So. | Flint, Mich. |
| OF | Adam Morris | Washington & Jefferson | Sr. | South Park, Pa. |
| DH | Kevin Cardentey | Adrian | Jr. | Cutler Bay, Fla. |
| UTL | Matt Evans | Saint Vincent | Sr. | New Brighton, Pa. |
| SP | Tate Ostrowski | Grove City | Jr. | Essex, Mass. |
| SP | Gino Sabatine | Marietta | Jr. | Alliance, Ohio |
| SP | Thomas Zbezinski | Penn State Behrend | Jr. | Gibsonia, Pa. |
| RP | Michael Zito | Washington & Jefferson | Sr. | Nashville, Tenn. |
| Third Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| C | Tanner Orner | Grove City | Sr. | Carlisle, Pa. |
| 1B | Branton Sanders | Anderson | Gr. | Whiteland, Ind. |
| 2B | Bobby Abbott | Grove City | Sr. | Westfield, N.J. |
| SS | Justin Reed | Anderson | So. | Martinsville, Ind. |
| 3B | Damian Yenzi | Marietta | Sr. | Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| OF | Colin Harger | Penn State Behrend | So. | Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| OF | Ben Hines | Wooster | Jr. | Farmington, Minn. |
| OF | Benjamin Stawicki | Case Western Reserve | Sr. | Aurora, Ohio |
| OF | Trent Youngblood | Transylvania | Fr. | Louisville, Ky. |
| DH | Tysen Lipscomb | Franklin | So. | Wapahani, Ind. |
| UTL | Zack Carinci | Case Western Reserve | Fr. | Twinsburg, Ohio |
| SP | Nick Drake | Washington & Jefferson | Sr. | Canonsburg, Pa. |
| SP | Thomas Gallant | Mount Union | Jr. | Pataskala, Ohio |
| SP | Jake Schmidt | Transylvania | Sr. | Dublin, Ohio |
| SP | Trevor VanDuyn | Calvin | Sr. | Jenison, Mich. |
| RP | Colin Springer | Wooster | Jr. | San Diego, Calif. |